Dave Winer points to this post about unscalable aggregators why he thinks presenting an aggregator’s output in reverse-chronological order is the best only way to do things. Not convincing. Three pane views, if correctly done (meaning an easy way to mark all as read, and easy keyboard navigation) makes it possible to go through large amounts of information relatively efficiently.
Tag Archives: Weblogging
Blogger Not So Bad
USS Clueless a post about how site after site is getting fed up with Blogger. The points (and their rebuttals) basically are:
- Archiving: Blogger v1 has many issues with archives. v2 (“Dano“) mostly fixes those, as I’ve seen in about a month of using a private Dano blog. I’ve haven’t had a disappearing archive post yet.
- Backups: It’s not as simple as CItyDesk or even MovableType, but it can be done. I’ll have a little more to say about local backups below.
- WYSIWYG Editing: w.bloggar does decent WYSIWYG editing for any host that supports the Blogger API — including MovableType.
Actually, the good Captain is spot on as usual — CityDesk is a far more friendly tool to use (I use it for the rest of chaoszone.org) but it is too expensive ($349) for the typical blogger (the Captain runs his own server — hardly a typical blogger). CityDesk’s home edition is capped at 500 items per database; not a lot, especially if you are prolific. I’ve wondered aloud in the CityDesk forums about a Weblogger’s Edition, but it is unlikely Fog Creek will take that up at this point of time.
Most bloggers have very kind words for MovableType. I agree, I use MT myself for a private blog in a server when I have shell access. However, it is a pain to set up when you don’t have shell access (such as my chaoszone.org account) and you don’t have a very responsive webhost (I’m in the process of switching now).
Here’s a little more on the “local backup” benefit of CityDesk. Most users I’ve seen actually have very lousy backup procedures. I’ve frequently seen home users back up their work on CDR or a different computer in their home and say their work is “safe”. Yeah, safe until a fire or quake. Now, the Captain may be backing up his work on a secure box in a backed-up data center on the East coast, but I bet most of the (especially non-tech) weblogging community isn’t doing anything like that. Blogger may hose your posts once in a while, but it will do so temporarily (I was hosed from April 2-10) and they can restore from backups. With CityDesk, or MovableType on an el cheapo no-backup (or weekly-backup) hosting plan, you are vulnerable — more so because you’ve been lulled into a false sense of security.
Bottom line? Think before you switch
.
New Blogger Version
Blogger’s switched me over to Dano — let’s see if archives work better now.
Army Capability and Empowerment
As a general rule, you can tell how good an army is and how well it will do on the battlefield by looking to see how much responsibility and authority it gives to its sergeants. And as De Atkine points out: “a sergeant first class in the U.S. Army has as much authority as a colonel in an Arab army”. The Israeli army’s sergeants are about the same as ours in terms of level of authority.
I wonder how the Indian and Pakistani armies would rate. Anyone with contacts in the military care to write about this?
Reverse-Chronological Aggregators
I am not sure why presenting an aggregator’s output in reverse-chronological order is the best way to do things.
RSS readers that work like Usenet readers are a waste of time, imho. Aggregators should not organize news by where items came from, just present the news in reverse chronologic order.
Actually, Radio’s aggregator doesn’t present the news in reverse-chronological order either: it presents it in reverse-chronological order ordered by feed. And while the reverse-chronological view may be useful, I am not convinced it is the only show in town. In particular, Radio’s implementation gives me information overload because the News Page bloats massively as I cross about 30 frequently updated or verbose subscriptions. IMHO Syndirella had a much better interface: no-frills, highly keyboard-friendly and geared to minimize visual overload.
Newfound Blogs
Good blogs I’ll queue up in my blogroll real soon now: madhoo.com, ravikiran.com and varnam.com.
Anna U. Blog Conference Was a Blast
I’m only about 10 days late (thanks, Blogger!) to thank Kribs, Anand and the fabulous crowd at Anna U MediaSciDept for doing such a great job at the National Panel Discussion on Blogging (which even got a Dave Winer Link, as well as some coverage from The Hindu). I had a great panelist in OJ (whose motorcycle just rocks, btw) who didn’t mind in the least as I blathered on.
To Anita: I live (and wait) in hope
To Kingsley, who’s full of good ideas: dunno if you’ve read this, but it sounds interesting and worth thinking about.
Ralph Peters on Iraq
Ralph Peters in the NY Post warns that while the war is going well for coalition troops, mistakes have been made:
Despite the warnings – even the pleading – of his generals, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld refused to send as many heavy ground forces to the Gulf as our military planners requested. In many ways an admirable and inspiring leader, Rumsfeld let himself be persuaded by a gang of civilian theorists and by mercenary defense contractors that airpower could win this war and that ground forces would just go in to tidy things up.So the generals did not get the extra armored divisions they wanted to provide maximum punch on the battlefield and as insurance should unexpected difficulties emerge. Now we have no significant ground reserves in the theater of war, we lack adequate combat units to fully protect our supply lines – and the weary troops at the front must continue the fight by themselves.
E-Bomb Targets Iraqi TV Station
Inside Ventura County: Iraqi TV Station was probably destroyed by E-bomb. Earlier, CNN had reported (can’t find a permalink for this) that the TV station was in a predominantly civilian area and that it was previously considered to be a “difficult” target in terms of minimizing civilian casualties.
LT Smash is a Great Read
LT Smash: After work today, a buddy and I grabbed a couple of cold beers, sat down on a park bench, and talked about football while watching the girls walk by. (LT Smash is a reserve officer in the US Military, blogging from the Gulf.)